(205) 701-5536

Our Blog

Blended Families Have a Higher Rate of WIll Contest Blended Families Have a Higher Rate of WIll Contest American Broadcasting Company (ABC)

Do You have a potential Will Contest?

Mar 19 2017 Staff

In modern America, estate and trust disputes, including will contest are getting more common.  There are likely many socioeconomic reasons for the rise in incidence, but as the baby boomer generation ages it is something many families and beneficiaries will need to address either before or after the passing of a loved one.

The first question when evaluating any potential will contest is whether the will contains an “unnatural disposition” of the testator’s property. Judges consider an unnatural disposition, along with other circumstances, in determining whether a will was a product of undue influence. Although proof of an unnatural disposition alone is not sufficient to invalidate a will, courts have long recognized that it is an early consideration for every will contest. As one court stated, an unnatural disposition is a “circumstance which should arouse the suspicion and strict scrutiny of the court[s].”

An unnatural disposition arises where the natural objects of a testator’s bounty are excluded from his or her will. Natural objects of a testator’s bounty generally include a spouse, descendants, and parents. Collateral heirs however, such as siblings, nieces, and nephews, do not automatically fit into this class. A disposition, even though unusual in an objective sense, or unnatural in the strictest legal meaning, will not be sufficient (standing alone) to overturn a will if there was a reasonable, logical, or rational basis for this particular testator to select the challenged disposition. However, an unexplained unnatural disposition may amount to evidence of lack of testamentary capacity or other suspicious circumstances.

Additionally, a disposition is unnatural if it creates an unequal division between persons who would normally take equal portions of the testator’s bounty—such as brothers and sisters. Yet this is not an absolute rule. For example, a testator’s disposition to one brother to the exclusion of his or her sisters is not necessarily unnatural where the testator was especially close to his or her brother.
 Similarly, unequal division of property between siblings because of family discord would usually not constitute an unnatural disposition.

A good rule of thumb as to what courts consider a natural object of the testator’s bounty, or what might be considered a natural disposition, is to follow the legislature’s dispositive scheme in the statutory provisions for intestate succession and the other public policy statutes affecting inheritance rights. However, because the very purpose for making a will may well be the testator’s desire to avoid the statutory rules of intestacy, these guidelines are obviously not conclusive, but they may well indicate a situation that needs to be investigated further and discussed with an attorney.


Rate this item
(2 votes)
Blog Use: Disclaimer

**This blog site is published on behalf of and reflects the personal views of the article authors, in their individual capacity. It does not necessarily represent the views of the law firm or any clients, and is not sponsored or endorsed by them. The purpose of this blog site is to assist in dissemination of information about general business and interesting legal topics, but no representation is made about the accuracy of the information. The information contained in this blog site is provided only as general information for education purposes, and blog topics may or may not be updated subsequent to their initial posting.

**By using this blog site you understand that this information is not provided in the course of an attorney-client relationship and is not intended to constitute legal advice. This blog site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed attorney in your state. This blog site is not intended to be advertising and Joshua M. Watkins does not wish to represent anyone desiring representation based upon viewing this blog site in a state where this blog site fails to comply with all laws and ethical rules of that state.

**No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.


In a world that has become increasingly complicated and uncertain, you deserve an attorney who is result-oriented, responsive and respected. 



Contact Info

4000 Eagle Point Corporate Dr. 
Birmingham, AL 35242

(205) 701-5536

 This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Office Hours 9.00 am to 5.00 pm
By Appointment Only

Twitter Feed

2019 Alabama Captive Insurance Conference dates announced - September 25-27 at Perdido Beach Resort
Good reminder to check your policies and procedures for online reviews.
Follow Joshua Watkins on Twitter